美丽琪迹-邵美琪国际影迷联盟

搜索
查看: 20739|回复: 44

[review] Blood of Good and Evil

[复制链接]
发表于 2006-10-7 07:08:43 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式

INDEX

1. Reviewer :  lotusgal @ SPCnet   (p.1)

2. Reviewers : multiple @ YesAsia  (p.1)

WE WELCOME YOUR REVIEW !!!

 

More info about BOGAE @ http://www.maggieshiu.net/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=967    (chinese)

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-10-7 7:53:49编辑过]
 楼主| 发表于 2006-10-7 07:18:33 | 显示全部楼层

http://www.spcnet.tv/reviews/review.php?rID=1006

Blood of Good and Evil
*Reviewed by lotusgal
  

 -- Full list of main characters --
   
Deric Wan Siu Lun --as-- Chai Hou Nam (a.k.a. Jeung Ji Chong)
Maggie Siu Mei Kei --as-- Shek Yee Ming
Tsang Kong --as-- Chai Kiu Jing
Law Lok Lum --as-- Jeung Ding Bong
Kitty Lai Mei Han --as-- Diane
Woo Foong --as-- Shek Cheung Chun
Lee Lum Lum --as-- Gan Wai Sum
Bak Yan --as-- Yip Kwai Chee (Cheung Chun's first wife)
Ng Woon Yee --as-- Yook Bing (Cheung Chun's second wife)
Dong Lan --as Chai Hou Yee
Nathan Chan Ting Wai --as-- Shek Kah Wing (Yook Bing's elder son)
Lum Lup Yeung (a.k.a. Lum Lei) --as-- Shek Kah Ho (Yook Bing's younger son)
Lam Yee Kei --as-- Fong Ling
Lam Bik Kei --as-- So Man
Chan Po Yee --as-- So Jing
Unknown actor --as-- Sam Go Jun Fung (the architect who pursues Diane)
Unknown actor --as-- Hing (Chai Kiu Jing's driver and right hand man)

 

Blood of Good and Evil (BOGE) is truly a TVB classic. It has all the critical elements of a successful TVB modern costume drama: Complicated plot with lots of characters, fast-paced story, a very strong cast with shining lead actor/actress, and great songs/music. More than a decade after it was first aired in Hong Kong, it is still in the list of most popular TVB drama list, next to all time classics like "Legend of Condor Heroes" (1983) and "Looking Back in Anger" (1989).


-- The classic good vs. evil theme --
   
A lot of TVB series centered around this good guy vs. bad guy theme. In BOGE, it's a cop vs. head of a mafia group. Stuck in between them is their son, Chai Hou Nam, who grew up looking up to his adoptive father, the mafia leader Chai Kiu Jing. Hou Nam is willing to sacrifice anything for Kiu Jing whether it's going to jail for a crime Kiu Jing committed, or letting Kiu Jing shoot him in the end. To Hou Nam, it had always been a natural thing to do, since Kiu Jing always tells him that when he retires, Hou Nam will take over his post as the mafia lead. Add to that influence is Hou Nam's mother by birth, Wai Sum, who always reminds him that he should listen to his adoptive father. Then comes Ding Bong, who is a top sergeant and biological father to Hou Nam, and who is determined to put Kiu Jing into jail. Hou Nam resisted Ding Bong at first because he is there to protect Kiu Jing and Wai Sum's interets. But slowly through Ding Bong and the encouragement of girlfriend Yee Ming, Hou Nam re-gains a sense of self and an understanding of what's right and wrong. Slowly and painfully, Hou Nam turns against Kiu Jing, with lots of twists and turns throughout. So here goes a perfect setting of this all-time favorite theme -- the good vs. the evil. And as always, the good side has to win in the end, but not without some deaths and blood shed.


  

-- The story --
    
Just like the pace of Hong Kong, this story flows at a steady and fast speed. The full version of this series is 40 episodes. I don't know if TVB cut down some scenes to fit on their official VCD release. It's not a short drama, but the script writer managed to keep it very entertaining to watch. I was hooked on it starting with the very first episode. The main plot centers around the battle between Kiu Jing and Ding Bong, and Hou Nam's inner struggle. Other than that, there are lots of subplots that keep the story flowing at a steady speed. Very typical of HK dramas in the 80's/early 90's is lots of death and tragedies in the end. I actually did a count of tragedies -- 9 of the 17 main characters above end in tragic death, incurable illness, escaping to spiritual life, or insanity.


-- Best scenes --
    
* The ending, where Hou Nam finds the blind Yee Ming, and tells her that she will be his wife forever.
* All scenes in England where Hou Nam and Yee Ming are together.
* Yee Ming chases her father Cheung Chun down to his apartment where she finds he has a second wife and two sons. This is so hilarious -- Yee Ming is with Cheung Chun's other wife, who has no idea that Yee Ming is Cheung Chun's daughter. Cheung Chun sees the two coming into his apartment, and embarrassedly told his other wife (Yook Bing) that Yee Ming is his niece.
* Another funny scene -- Yee Ming stares at Hou Nam's picture inside his bedroom. Hou Nam suddenly comes out of no where and she is so embarrased. Then Wai Sum comes in and asks Hou Nam to drive Yee Ming home. Yee Ming rushes out of the Chai's mansion. Hou Nam drives behind her and asks the unwilling Yee Ming to get in his car. The two start a hilarious quarrel. Yee Ming gets out of the car in the end.
* Towards the end, Kiu Jing shoots Hou Nam in the knee. Hou Nam is heartbroken and says that he is letting the bullet pays back the 20 or so years Kiu Jing has provided him. A very moving scene.


-- An excellent cast --
    
Deric Wan is simply superb in this show. No wonder it shot his career up into the high sky. A lot of his fans think this is his all time best role. He is equally convincing playing both a villain and a good guy. To protect Kiu Jing, Hou Nam plots to kill his enemies and can be ruthless to people who gets into his father's way. But inside his hard shell, he is compassionate and even loving. Deric did well from start to finish showing a gradual transition. Maggie Siu is in one of her best role as a strong woman who pulls Hou Nam back into the right track. Her short hairstyle was her trademark at the time. The entire cast, I mean every one of them, did an excellent job. Wardrobe fits each character quite well too. I especially like Diane's hair, with the twisted side ponytail which made her look special.


   

-- The music --
     
Since some of the scenes are filmed in England, there is quite a number of English songs in the series. All of the songs and supporting music are not only good, but the lyrics actutally make sense to what's happening when the music/song is played. Some interesting examples are:

* Gimme What You Got (by Don Henley) -- Sung when Hou Nam is being chased by gangster members in London and wounded. The gangster lead plots to capture Hou Nam for the purpose of luring Kiu Jing to come to London for his son.
* Maggie (by Rod Stewart) -- Isn't this done on purpose?! It's actually Maggie Siu's solo scene.
* I Will Wait For You (by Andy Williams) -- The story is at Hou Nam leaving Diane's grave in deep sadness. Yee Ming follows Hou Nam's car which was driven down a cliff. Yee Ming sits at the edge of the cliff waiting and crying, and then Hou Nam miraculously climbs back up.
* Crush (Um Luin, by Shirley Kwan) -- Sung when Hou Yee first met Kah Wing. It was love at first sight (Hou Yee's crush on Kah Wing).


So in conclusion, even after all these years, this is DEFINITELY a must watch for all fans of HK drama, Deric Wan and Maggie Shiu, and anyone who wants good entertainment.

Rating: It's such a great drama that there just aren't enough stars for it.

General plots of the story (in English):
http://www.angelfire.com/stars3/msseries/bogaestory.html
     
http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/polanski/795/summaries/blood.htm

   

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-10-7 7:54:28编辑过]
发表于 2006-10-7 07:20:56 | 显示全部楼层

Maggie looks like a tomboy

 楼主| 发表于 2006-10-7 07:30:59 | 显示全部楼层

http://us.yesasia.com/en/Reviews/CustReview.aspx?section=videos&code=c&version=all&pid=1004066882&

Blood Of Good And Evil

General Review by YesAsia :

 Thanks to Blood of Good and Evil, Deric Wan and Maggie Shiu rose to fame quickly in the early 1990s. In the drama Deric Wan is Nam, a young man with a promising career in his step-father Ching's enterprise. A righteous cop has been after Ching for years because Ching makes money by all sorts of illegal means. Failed to arrest Ching, he succeeds in gathering evidence to put Nam into jail. However, only at this point he realizes Nam is actually his biological son! Maggie Shiu plays a charismatic girl Ming in Blood of Good and Evil who falls in love with Nam. Her father, however, has been in bad terms with Ching for years... The TV epic involves love-hate relationships among three families across two generations, and they have to make difficult choices one after another!

Customers Review :

Reviewer: lightening fast  Best of TVB!

This gotta be one of TVB's best shows in their entire history! It's that bloody good. Deric Wan's Chai Ho Nam will forever leave a remarkable spot in TVB's history. His portrayal of the complicated Ho Nam is not only semi-good/semi-evil, but classy, elegant and has that star presence on screen. And as for the other star Maggie Siu, she completely redefined beauty. Before BOGE, I never found any women looking that good in short hair and with a very strong personality. Enough said, just go grab the VCDs! It's actually UNCUT, isnt that amazing too.

Reviewer: AC  Good news - Finally an uncut TVB drama

I first hesitated to buy this drama as I knew that ALL earlier TVB VCD dramas were edited with scenes cut out. Always loved this drama and had waited so long for it to come out. Finally it was released. Before purchasing, I confirmed and reconfirmed with the seller that this is an UNCUT version. So glad that the seller did not lie....I have just completed Part 1 of this drama, all scenes in place, all background music unchanged. Video transfer NOT seems to be digitally remastered, colours OK but images are a little dull. Well...the drama is slightly over 13 years old, they probably did not need to revise it like some older dramas. Anyway, as long as it is the same version as aired, I am satisfied. The only editing done was fitting all the original episodes onto 24 discs (12 x 2 box sets). In part 1, the title song appears once only on Disc#1. Will start on Part 2 soon.

Reviewer: Puppet  Is Blood Thicker Than Water?

Blood of Good and Evil is easily the greatest TVB production. The series had won numerous awards including the most watched TVB series in the 90s. It came 4th in TVB Anniversary Award for most watched TVB drama only behind masterpieces like Looking Back In Anger, which also starred the two main cast of Blood of Good and Evil - namely Deric Wan Siu Lun and Maggie Siu Mei Kei. Both actors were hailed the most talented actors for TVB of all time and has often been named the golden couple in the 90s. After a successful casting in Looking Back In Anger, Deric and Maggie was reunited in this well-written and excellently produced drama which instantly launched the career of both actors, forever sealing their reputation in TVB history.
Although following the familiar plot of most TVB big production, i.e. the story of familial rivalry - Blood of Good and Evil is unique in its twist and turn. It follows a journey of self-discovery of its protagonist, Chai Ho Nam (Deric Wan) - who the audience is first introduced as the son of Hong Kong's most influential and powerful gangster, Chai Kiu Cheng (Chang Kong). His initial appearance in Blood is reminiscent of his evil character in Looking Back In Anger. However, we gradually followed his journey as he started to discover the humane side of his character through the intricately woven narratives of his family history. It is as though TVB is aiming to metamorphasized this talented actor from an evil creature and transformed him into a tortured soul of torn loyalty and love. Such transformation come with a price of course which involve the lost of love and sacrifices.
Without wanting to give away the story, the narrative unfolds when we see Ho Nam was later sent to prison as an expression of loyalty to his father who committed a murder. The case has led to the suicide of Ho Nam's first girlfriend Dianne, (Kitty Lai)who befriended the murder victim and witnessed the murder. His murder investigation was handled by a no-nonsense and fiercely competent Detective, Cheung Ding Pong (Lo Lok Lum) who we later discovered was Ho Nam's biological father. This marks the beginning of Ho Nam's journey from hatred to love, from evil to good. Yet along his journey, he made many choices to hold on to his loyalty to his much love adopted father which ended in many sacrifes including his one true love for Shek Yee Ming (Maggie Siu Mei Kei)- a British Born Chinese who later return to Hong Kong and worked as a journalist for a magazine.
The narrative between Ho Nam and Yee Ming is particularly moving and heart-warming as she played a big part in helping Ho Nam in his transformation. Ho Nam first met Yee Ming while on a "mission" in London where Yee Ming was born. His father so-called Blood brother aimed to kill Ho Nam as a mean of expanding his power over Kiu Cheng and to get rid of his London's underground rival. Yee Ming saved Ho Nam when he was pursued by the London gangster. Unbeknown to Ho Nam, Yee Ming was a friend of Ho Nam's sister, Chai Ho Yee (Tung Nam) who at the time was studying Art in London. She went to the same college as Yee Ming who at the time was pursuing her degree in journalism. Unfortunately this had led the London's gangster to kidnap Yee Ming, whom they mistaken to be Ho Nam's sister. This had then led to Ho Nam having to rescue Yee Ming.
I guess I should stop telling the full story. Just a taster and a brief summary of why you should purchase this excellent series
- believable and unique script which break away from the usual and tired story line of family rivalry, revenge etc.
- a moving plot of a loyalty torn between good and evil. Is blood really thicker than water? If you think Cold Blood Warm Heart is great, well think where its get its inspiration?
- a moving love story between father and son. A romantic story of two lovers who make sacrifices for each other
- a well cast masterpiece with excellent near perfection performance from TVB's most talented actors, Deric Wan, Maggie Siu, Kitty Lai, Wu Fun, Lo Lok Lum, Nathan Chan
- great cinematography with stunning scenery of London, Macau and Hong Kong
- Great humour from Wu Fung and Maggie Siu
- A very moving but surprising ending - this ending is one of the most memorable yet

Enough Said. Buy it and Enjoy It

Puppet


I have just finished watching Blood of Good and Evil (Part 1). It has been 9 years since. Now I can't wait for Part 2 to arrive.
Unlike Part 1, Part 2 focused more on the main narrative and the intricate relationships between characters are starting to unfold. It takes a slighly more serious turn while Part 1 is laden with comic reliefs from Wu Fung.
How will Ho Nam reacts when he finds out who his biological father was?
Will Yee Ming be able to tolerate Ho Nam's relationship with his adopted father?
How will Kiu Ching reacts when he is presented with the fact that blood is indeed thicker than water?
Part 2 is jammed pack with stunning views of London, more fantastic 90s soundtrack. Also feature the fantastic collaboration between the late Anita Mui and Andy Hui.
I can't bloody wait!

Reviewer: ramen   One of the best TVB series of all time !
This must be one of the best series ever produced by TVB. Excellent performance from all casts esp deric wan and maggie siu. Really good story and great sceneries in UK. After watching this series, i fell in love completely with both of teh main casts !

Reviewer: JoJo   Fall in Love with BOGAE
This series captured my heart when I first watched it. You can’t help but get immersed in the dialogue and the characters alike. There are moments of laughter, sadness, and memorable romance. I have yet to find another TVB pair comparable to Deric Wan and Maggie Siu. The soundtrack is so nicely integrated into the scenes (especially of London) that you will start to reminisce the late 1980s and early 1990s. You will fall in love with BOGAE.

Reviewer: Chris   Finally....

Finally, I have a chance to own a copy of this masterpiece. (I have re-watched this many time from my taped recording copy) There is no doubt that this is one of the best drama series ever produced by TVB.
A great cast with a great display of acting skills by Deric Wan!


发表于 2006-10-7 21:41:49 | 显示全部楼层

one of my favourite, thanks so much!

but i bought the one without copy right, so pity, the quality is too bad

发表于 2006-10-7 22:37:03 | 显示全部楼层

Thanks a lot,shaw!

发表于 2006-10-8 02:11:46 | 显示全部楼层

Thanks shaw

I'm a little ashamed to admit that I still haven't finished this from start to finish

Shaw, are you going to post some of her other reviews, or would you like me to scour around and post them?

 楼主| 发表于 2006-10-8 09:53:40 | 显示全部楼层
QUOTE:
以下是引用charmed在2006-10-8 2:11:46的发言:

Thanks shaw

I'm a little ashamed to admit that I still haven't finished this from start to finish

Shaw, are you going to post some of her other reviews, or would you like me to scour around and post them?

charmed, post any credible reviews you found. I am just initiating it. Your cooperation is highly welcome.

发表于 2006-10-8 18:56:13 | 显示全部楼层

BOAGE,MY ALL TIME FAVOURITE!

发表于 2006-10-9 13:32:29 | 显示全部楼层

Yay!!  I finally get to leave a message.  Hi all!  I'm JoJo.  Thanks Shaw_Mag for helping with registration instructions.  I finally got through.  I'm a huge fan of BOGAE!! 

I finally finished watching CIB ... I wish there were more wong he and maggie scenes together ... the romance between them was quite rushed ...

What is Maggie working on now?  Alright ...time to read all the pages in this forum to catch up on the latest Maggie news.

Thanks for all the great images everyone.  You all are awesome.

JoJo from USA.

发表于 2006-10-9 14:13:50 | 显示全部楼层
QUOTE:
以下是引用jobogae在2006-10-9 13:32:29的发言:

Yay!!  I finally get to leave a message.  Hi all!  I'm JoJo.  Thanks Shaw_Mag for helping with registration instructions.  I finally got through.  I'm a huge fan of BOGAE!! 

I finally finished watching CIB ... I wish there were more wong he and maggie scenes together ... the romance between them was quite rushed ...

What is Maggie working on now?  Alright ...time to read all the pages in this forum to catch up on the latest Maggie news.

Thanks for all the great images everyone.  You all are awesome.

JoJo from USA.

Welcome, JoJo.

Maggie is busy working for the film of PTU 2.

发表于 2006-10-10 11:46:59 | 显示全部楼层
QUOTE:
以下是引用jobogae在2006-10-9 13:32:29的发言:

Yay!!  I finally get to leave a message.  Hi all!  I'm JoJo.  Thanks Shaw_Mag for helping with registration instructions.  I finally got through.  I'm a huge fan of BOGAE!! 

I finally finished watching CIB ... I wish there were more wong he and maggie scenes together ... the romance between them was quite rushed ...

What is Maggie working on now?  Alright ...time to read all the pages in this forum to catch up on the latest Maggie news.

Thanks for all the great images everyone.  You all are awesome.

JoJo from USA.

Hi Jojo~~ Are you oJo making a wallpaper of Wong Hei and Maggie in English forum?
发表于 2006-10-10 14:20:32 | 显示全部楼层

I'm still trying to get adjusted to an all Chinese forum...don't know how I can add my Maggie signature .. is that something I can do here?  Is it just me or is it my avatar is really really small.

I probably will not be creating a Wong He and Maggie poster.  Instead I'm still dreaming of a Deric Wan and Maggie reunion again ... which I don't think would be likely but...*sigh*...I think I'm going to find time to create a poster of Maggie and Deric...my own dream series hehehe....will share when it is done.

发表于 2006-10-10 14:52:52 | 显示全部楼层
QUOTE:
以下是引用jobogae在2006-10-10 14:20:32的发言:

I'm still trying to get adjusted to an all Chinese forum...don't know how I can add my Maggie signature .. is that something I can do here?  Is it just me or is it my avatar is really really small.

I probably will not be creating a Wong He and Maggie poster.  Instead I'm still dreaming of a Deric Wan and Maggie reunion again ... which I don't think would be likely but...*sigh*...I think I'm going to find time to create a poster of Maggie and Deric...my own dream series hehehe....will share when it is done.

Probably you should reset the size of your icon.

For setting your signature in this forum, it's a little bit diffucult to explain if you can not read Chinese.

 楼主| 发表于 2006-10-10 15:15:33 | 显示全部楼层

Welcome, jojo!

too bad i don't have time to make picture tutorial on signature setting, etc. Any volunteers?

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 加入琪迹

本版积分规则

手机版|小黑屋|美丽琪迹-邵美琪国际影迷联盟 ( 10014773 )

GMT+8, 2025-4-30 07:07

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

© 2001-2023 Discuz! Team.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表