[Review] Tactical Unit - The Code

shaw_mag

TV Movie TACTICAL UNIT - THE CODE [《機動部隊》之 《警例》]

(The Code is 1st part of four TV Movies "Tactical Unit" by Milkyway Image; the 5th part will be a theatrical movie)

[The whole 5 sets of "Tactical Unit": 《機動部隊》之 《警例》， 《絕路》，《伙伴》，《人性》+ 《 同袍》]

-----

Review Index:

1. by Maggie Lee of Hollywood Reporter --- p.1

2. by Kozo of Lovehkfilm --- p.1

shaw_mag

Hollywood Reporter

Film Review: Tactical Unit -- The Code

BOTTOM LINE: A slow-boiling police story brimming with warm human interest.

June 11, 2008

By Maggie Lee

Udine Far East Film Festival

UDINE, Italy -- Johnnie To's trademark advocacy of team work and professionalism as the cornerstone of social order is intelligently challenged in "Tactical Unit - The Code." Produced by To and executed by his company Milkyway Image, it marks an unostentatious and grounded treatment of a character-driven police story by veteran editor Law Wing-Cheong, in his second stint as solo director.

The first of four telefeatures capped by a fifth episode made for the screen, the project is circumscribed by its small production scale, and is unlikely to make it to theaters in stand-alone form. Overseas TV slots and DVD shelf life depend on how other episodes turn out.

Law examines the pros and cons of going by the book or bending the rules to get the job done. An internal investigation on some unclear footage of PTU officers thrashing a suspect triggers a race to find said suspect by rival parties. Meanwhile, PTU officer Eight (Lee Kwok-lun) loses his grip when obedience to staff procedure results in demotion. The crisis escalates when teammates must choose between covering their tracks and coming to Eight's aid.

Since the success of "Infernal Affairs," Hong Kong films have portrayed the police force as a den of moles and counter-moles ad absurdum. At last, there's a film showing solidarity across the ranks, while pointing out the fine line between team spirit and simply looking out for one's own.

Those lured by To or Milkyway's label to expect the high-handed cinematic flourishes of "The Mission" or "Exiled" better not hold their breath. Law coordinates action with the technical finish of an artisan, not the style-consciousness of an auteur. Keeping pace of the linear script on an even keel, the first hour simmers without a spark. But in the last 20 minutes, a double stake-out brings tensions to a boil through fluid shooting in compact interiors of a police station.

Opposite to the bluesy nocturnal mood of its predecessor "PTU," the visual texture of "Tactical Unit" (shot mostly in daytime on video) has a slightly dull sheen that deglamorizes the sphere of operation.

Milkyway Image (HK) Limited

Cast: Simon Yam, Maggie Siu, Lee Kwok-lun, Lam Suet.

Director-editor: Law Wing-Cheong .
Screenwriter: Yip Tin-shing.
Producer: Johnnie To.
Executive Producer: Daniel Lam
Directors of photography: Chan Siu-kwan, Tsou Lin-yau.
Art director: Sukie Yip.
Music: Tomy Wai.
Sales: Universe Films Distribution Co. Ltd.
No rating, 90 minutes.

shaw_mag

Lovehkfilm.com

Never equate television with the movies. With that caveat, Tactical Unit - The Code can survive initial scrutiny, and qualify as a competent, interesting cop drama. Stare long enough however, and this TV movie isn't worthy of the Milkyway logo or Johnnie To's producer credit. Factor in this telefilm's sequel status to a little movie called PTU, and disappointment is all but guaranteed. The positives: it has Simon Yam, Lam Suet, and Maggie Siu, plus they play cops. For a movie, that's not such a huge deal, but for television, it's pretty damn awesome. Tactical Unit - The Code is television, so it gets a generous pass. Kindness - or measured judgement via reduced expectations - is a virtue.

The crew from PTU returns for Tactical Unit - The Code, the first of five PTU spinoff films that curiously do not bear the PTU name.The Code was directed by Law Wing-Cheong (Hooked on You, Two Become One), and boasts a competent script from Yip Tin-Shing (writer of too many Milkyway productions to mention). Simon Yam, Maggie Siu, and Lam Suet reprise their original roles, and are aided by Teddy Lin Chun as a senior officer, plus various unfamiliar and also familiar faces, many of whom belong to the Milkyway stable of bit players. The themes of The Code are also familiar, echoing the "cops look out for one another" creed explored so stylishly in Johnnie To's award-winning 2003 film.

The Code, however, is a lot less stylish than PTU, partially because of the telefilm's obvious lack of production values. Staging here is a bit more leaden, and Tommy Wai's score has nothing on Chung Chi-Wing's playful accompaniment to the original feature. The TV film occasionally surprises with decent lighting and art direction, recalling the dark locations and bright pools of overhead light that characterized the original film. However, that's only occasionally; at other times the film attempts terribly obvious day-for-night cinematography, and even places much of its action during the day to do away with complicated night setups. The result: a less cinematic feel, both visually and emotionally, as the stark urban atmosphere of the original is reduced to something only a shade above your average TVB drama.

Even more, the script lacks the humor and inventive surprise of the theatrical film, aiming for solid, but unremarkable cop drama. A traffic camera records an incident involving a triad member getting brutalized by three PTU officers, and members of the squad led by Sam (Simon Yam) are under suspicion. Tensions are raised between the PTU and CAPO (Complaints Against Police Office), and the whole thing is fit to burst when the suspect in a recent assault also turns out to be the caught-on-tape police brutality victim. The various teams race against each other to find the suspect/victim, with more at stake than just a single case. The outcome of the hunt could ruin the careers of decent cops, whose transgressions may be the result of nothing more than high tensions on a bad day. Will black-and-white justice or subjective shades of gray prevail?

Tactical Unit - The Code earns points for its themes, as well as its attempts to humanize Hong Kong's law enforcement individuals. These are civil servants with demanding jobs, and asking them to be perfectly behaved automatons impervious to daily stress would simply be too much. The Code presents this as rationale for its flawed cops, while also not excusing their other possible vices (in particular, the telefilm portrays many of the cops as being in exceptional debt). This attention to theme and character raises the Code from average to good television, though the uninspiring manner in which the whole is presented drops everything back down a notch. Johnnie To completists may still wish to check out The Code for its perfunctory Milkyway Image signifiers. However, expectations should be adjusted accordingly, as the telefilm only shows potential and doesn't truly capitalize upon it. One hopes that the subsequent Tactical Unit telefilms can improve upon the promise glimpsed in this initial outing. The fifth film in the series is a must-see, however: it'll be shot in 35mm and directed by Johnnie To. I'm guessing it should be much better than The Code. It should also be judged much more harshly. (Kozo, Reviewed at the Udine Far East Film Festival, 2008)

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-6-12 20:25:07编辑过]